A youthful lesbian duo, Candice (Brooklyn Gray) and Abby (Phoenix Askani), are spending quality time together. As Candice tenderly combs and arranges Abby's hair, they remain oblivious to the watchful eyes of Abby's father, Ethan (Ryan Driller), who is captivated by Candice's physique. When they finally engage Ethan in conversation, asking his opinion on Abby's new hairstyle, he deflects suspicion with a light-hearted quip. Days later, Abby is visibly distressed and Ethan inquires about her troubles. Abby reveals that she and Candice were invited to a friend's sleepover, but the invitation was withdrawn due to the intolerant views of the friend's parents, who disapprove of their lesbian relationship. Ethan proposes that Abby could invite Candice over for their own private sleepover. Abby is thrilled by the suggestion, unaware of Ethan's hidden agenda. During the night, as Candice and Abby peacefully sleep in Abby's bed, Ethan tosses a pillow towards Candice and swiftly retreats into the corridor. Candice awakens, confused about what transpired, and stumbles into the hallway, encountering Ethan. He inquires about her well-being, and Candice dismisses the incident as a bad dream. Ethan extends an invitation to have a casual conversation in the living room, hoping it would help Candice unwind. They engage in idle chatter, which gradually drifts towards Candice's relationship with Abby. Ethan questions the depth of their bond. Candice is certain of their closeness, but Ethan subtly sows seeds of doubt by revealing intimate details about Abby's upbringing and feigning surprise when Candice admits her ignorance of these facts. Ethan suggests that maybe Candice and Abby are more akin to friends than lovers, and probes Candice's certainty about her sexuality. He advises that it would be prudent to ascertain her preferences before their relationship escalates, to spare Abby any future heartbreak. He also expresses concern for Candice, mentioning that he thinks she's a great individual and he wouldn't want her to be hurt by investing too much in a potential mistake. Candice becomes anxious, and Ethan poses a question: has Candice ever considered being intimate with a man? Candice confesses that she has never been intimate with a man, and Ethan advises that it could be a worthwhile exploration to affirm her sexuality. Candice is taken aback by the proposition of seeking a male partner for this purpose, as it would feel like a betrayal to Abby. At this point, Ethan volunteers himself as a potential partner, which astounds Candice even more. Ethan assures her that it's safer to embark on this journey with a trustworthy person, and since his intentions are rooted in concern for Abby's happiness, it can't be considered betrayal. He continues his persuasive charm and eventually, Candice consents. It's all for Abby's well-being... isn't it?